Policybazaar and the Commission Question: What Just Happened, and Why It’s Too Early to Panic

On September 24, 2026, PB Fintech – the company behind Policybazaar and Paisabazaar – had one of the worst days in its listed history. The stock fell 36% in a single session, from about ₹1,886 to ₹1,207 (Marketcalls). It closed Friday at ₹1166.0, roughly 37% below where it started the week.

Nothing went wrong inside the company that day. Just six weeks earlier, it had reported one of its strongest quarters ever. What changed was a document from the insurance regulator, IRDAI, proposing to cap how much insurers can pay the people who sell their policies.

To understand why that matters so much for Policybazaar, let’s start with how insurance actually gets sold.

TL;DR:

IRDAI’s proposed insurance commission caps sent PB Fintech’s stock tumbling after investors feared a direct hit to Policybazaar’s revenue. The company earns commissions from policies sold on its platform, while insurers treat those payments as a cost. The proposed rules could sharply reduce payouts for products such as motor and health insurance. However, the proposal is still under consultation, and Policybazaar’s growing renewals, large customer base and other businesses provide potential offsets. The final impact will depend on how IRDAI’s rules evolve and how insurers and distributors adapt.

How Insurance Commissions Work

Most people don’t buy insurance directly from an insurer. They buy it through someone- an agent, a bank, a car dealer, or a website like Policybazaar. The insurer pays that seller a cut of your premium. That cut is the commission.

A few simple things to know:

• The first year pays the most. Sellers usually earn a large chunk of the first year’s premium and a much smaller slice at each renewal after that. At HDFC Life, for example, commissions were 38.7% of the first-year premium in FY26 but only 1.6% of the renewal premium (Motilal Oswal).
• It’s a cost for one side and income for the other. For an insurer, commission is a cost of finding a customer. For a seller like Policybazaar, commission is the business.

That second point explains almost everything that happened in the market this week.

Commissions Have Been Rising Fast

In April 2023, IRDAI loosened its rules. Instead of capping commissions product by product, it set one overall limit on how much an insurer could spend in total, and let each insurer decide how to split it (AZB & Partners).

Insurers did what you’d expect: they spent more on commissions to win customers. You can see it in their numbers.

Sources: Motilal Oswal, Emkay Global.

Across the industry, the regulator found that commissions paid to insurance brokers jumped about 173% between FY23 and FY25 – from roughly ₹6,348 crore to ₹17,348 crore – far faster than premiums grew (IRDAI Consultation Paper, Part 2).

Where Policybazaar Fits In

Policybazaar is a broker. It earns money when you compare and buy a policy on its platform. The simplest way to think about its business is its take rate, the share of every premium rupee it keeps as revenue.

In the April–June 2026 quarter, the take rate for its core online insurance business was 18.5%, up from 17.9% a year earlier (Motilal Oswal). In plain terms: for every ₹100 of premium customers paid through Policybazaar, the company earned about ₹18.50.

Business was booming. That quarter, PB Fintech’s revenue grew 40% to ₹1,888 crore, and profit nearly doubled. Its renewal income – money that keeps coming in as old customers renew – grew 55% to ₹1,003 crore over the past 12 months. The platform had 158.9 million registered users and 28.1 million paying customers (PB Fintech Q1FY27 earnings call; Motilal Oswal).

What IRDAI Was Saying Before the Proposal

The regulator had been dropping hints for months. In public interviews, IRDAI’s leadership discussed “effort-based” commissions – the idea that sellers should be paid according to how much work a sale actually takes. IRDAI Chairman Ajay Seth, who, soon after taking charge in 2025, told insurers that distributor commissions were too high (Deccan Chronicle), also said there was “no case for commission” on motor third-party insurance, since it’s mandatory by law and people have to buy it anyway (as discussed on the ICICI Lombard and Go Digit earnings calls, July 2026).

The market read “effort-based” as a warning for online platforms. The worry: if a customer can buy a policy with a few clicks, does the seller really deserve a large commission?

How Policybazaar’s Management Responded

When analysts raised this on the August 5 earnings call, Policybazaar’s leadership pushed back firmly, but politely.

CEO Yashish Dahiya’s argument was simple: under IRDAI’s own rules, a broker is required to do more work than any other kind of seller – sales, customer support, policy issuance and claims help. “So it’s a very difficult position to take,” he said, that the seller expected to put in the most effort should somehow be seen as doing less. Asked about a worst case, he said: “Don’t even think about the worst case scenario.”

He also explained where the real effort goes. Building a website is the easy part, he said there are about 300 platforms where you can buy insurance. The hard, expensive work is finding interested customers, convincing them to buy, and standing by them when they make a claim. Policybazaar helped with about 70,000 health insurance claims in that quarter alone.

Joint CEO Sarbvir Singh added that demand for insurance in India is “extremely low” and fades quickly after every boost, whether after COVID or after the recent GST exemption. Anyone selling insurance, he said, has to make a real effort to get there.

What IRDAI Is Now Proposing

The consultation paper, released on September 23, puts firm numbers on the table. For large distributors like Policybazaar, some of the proposed limits are:

• Motor third-party insurance: no commission on new policies
• Motor own-damage insurance: 5% on new policies
• Individual health insurance: 15% in the first year, 5% on renewals
• Marketing and tech spending would count inside these limits, so insurers can’t pay extra through the back door

Individual agents would get somewhat higher limits than large distributors under the draft the point Policybazaar’s management had argued against. Insurers would also have to bring their overall expenses down over the next two to five years. The regulator is taking public feedback until October 25, 2026.

How This Could Affect Policybazaar

Because commission is Policybazaar’s revenue, any cut lands directly on its top line. And because most of its costs – staff, marketing, technology – don’t shrink automatically, a small drop in revenue can mean a big drop in profit.

Analysts have tried to put numbers on it:

• Macquarie estimates that a 2-point cut in the take rate (say, from 18.5% to 16.5%) could reduce PB Fintech’s operating profit (EBITDA) by about 25%.
• Jefferies estimates that every 10% cut in commissions could reduce earnings by 10–12% (IndMoney).

Motor insurance is one area to watch. Management has said that third-party cover accounts for about a quarter of its direct-to-customer motor premium and about half of the motor business sold through its agent network (PB Fintech Q1FY27 earnings call). Under the draft, new third-party policies would earn nothing.

How the Stock Reacted

The fall was sharper than for any insurer. That makes sense: for insurers, lower commissions mean lower costs. ICICI Lombard’s stock actually rose 5% on the same day. Only companies that earn commissions, like PB Fintech, were hit this hard (Marketcalls).

Why It’s Too Early to Panic

A 38% fall is painful, and the risk is real. But there are good reasons not to treat this draft as the final word.

1. It’s a proposal, not a rule. IRDAI has asked for feedback, and insurers, brokers, and agents will respond before October 25. Final limits could be softer, phased in more slowly, or structured differently.
2. Policybazaar has a strong case to make. The argument that brokers do the most legally required work is not just talk. It’s written into the rules brokers operate under. Under the IRDAI (Insurance Brokers) Regulations, 2018, a broker works on behalf of the customer, not the insurer. Its listed duties include understanding the customer’s needs, advising on the appropriate cover and terms, obtaining quotes from multiple insurers, assisting with policy issuance and premium payments, and assisting with claims (IRDAI Insurance Brokers Regulations, 2018). An agent, by comparison, is appointed by and sells for the insurer, yet the draft would give agents higher commission limits than large distributors. Expect it to feature heavily in the feedback.
3. The business underneath is growing fast. Revenue up 40%, profit nearly doubling and renewal income up 55%; these are the numbers of a company that customers keep choosing. Management has said it expects renewal growth to stay “upwards of 50% for some time.”
4. Insurers still need someone to sell for them. India remains badly under-insured, and insurers need platforms that can find, convince and support customers at scale. Lower commissions change the economics, but they don’t remove the need.
5. There’s more to PB Fintech than one product. Paisabazaar’s credit business, the new PB Health venture and a large customer base give the company other levers to pull if insurance margins get squeezed.
6. A lot of the bad news is already priced in. The stock has already lost more than a third of its value on the draft alone before any final decision.

None of this means the proposal is harmless. If the draft passes as written, Policybazaar’s profits would likely take a meaningful hit, at least for a while. But the gap between a draft and a final rule is often wide, and the next few weeks will matter a lot.

We’re On Top of This

We’re following this closely, the feedback process, IRDAI’s final rules, and what Policybazaar’s management says and does next, including in its upcoming quarterly results. As the picture becomes clearer, we’ll share updates on what it means for the business and for your portfolio.

Sources

• IRDAI, Consultation Paper on Distribution Reforms, Parts 1 and 2 (September 2026) – Part 2
• AZB & Partners, Liberalisation of Norms Governing Payment of Commissions by Insurers
• LSEG StreetEvents earnings call transcripts (Q1FY27): PB Fintech (August 5, 2026); ICICI Lombard and HDFC Life (July 15, 2026); Go Digit (July 23, 2026)
• Motilal Oswal results updates: PB Fintech (August 5, 2026); ICICI Lombard and HDFC Life (July 15, 2026); Max Financial Services (August 13, 2026)
• Emkay Global, Go Digit results update (July 24, 2026)
• IndMoney, Marketcalls, Business Today (September 2026)

Stock prices as of September 25, 2026 (intraday). This article is for information only and is not investment advice.

_{Disclaimer: Investment in securities market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing. Registration granted by SEBI, membership of a SEBI recognized supervisory body (if any) and certification from NISM in no way guarantee performance of the intermediary or provide any assurance of returns to investors.}

_{The content in these posts/articles is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as professional financial advice and nor to be construed as an offer to buy /sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy/sell any security or financial products.Users must make their own investment decisions based on their specific investment objective and financial position and using such independent advisors as they believe necessary.}

_{Windmill Capital Team: Windmill Capital Private Limited is a SEBI registered research analyst (Regn. No. INH200007645) based in Bengaluru at No 51 Le Parc Richmonde, Richmond Road, Shanthala Nagar, Bangalore, Karnataka – 560025 creating Thematic & Quantamental curated stock/ETF portfolios. Data analysis is the heart and soul behind our portfolio construction & with 50+ offerings, we have something for everyone. CIN of the company is U74999KA2020PTC132398. For more information and disclosures, visit our disclosures page here.}